For Whom the Bell Tolls
- Downloads：7680
- Type：Epub+TxT+PDF+Mobi
- Create Date：2021-05-05 11:58:52
- Update Date：2025-09-06
- Status：finish
- Author：Ernest Hemingway
- ISBN：0099908603
- Environment：PC/Android/iPhone/iPad/Kindle
- Download
Summary
In 1937 Ernest Hemingway traveled to Spain to cover the civil war there for the North American Newspaper Alliance。 Three years later he completed the greatest novel to emerge from "the good fight，" For Whom the Bell Tolls。 The story of Robert Jordan， a young American in the International Brigades attached to an antifascist guerilla unit in the mountains of Spain， it tells of loyalty and courage， love and defeat， and the tragic death of an ideal。 In his portrayal of Jordan's love for the beautiful Maria and his superb account of El Sordo's last stand， in his brilliant travesty of La Pasionaria and his unwillingness to believe in blind faith， Hemingway surpasses his achievement in The Sun Also Rises and A Farewell to Arms to create a work at once rare and beautiful， strong and brutal， compassionate， moving and wise。 "If the function of a writer is to reveal reality，" Maxwell Perkins wrote to Hemingway after reading the manuscript， "no one ever so completely performed it。" Greater in power， broader in scope， and more intensely emotional than any of the author's previous works， it stands as one of the best war novels of all time。
Reviews
Hannah Kwon
，
This is a classic by Ernest Hemingway and I think it's one of the easiest classics。 Classics usually take brain energy and willpower to read but not this one。 The plot wasn't even that fun… just some Robert Jordan meeting a guerilla to blow up a bridge。 It was a detailed description of what happens in about the duration of 4 days， and as concise as that is， I got to really experience a part of war that I couldn't have before。 Made me think about death a lot！ This is a classic by Ernest Hemingway and I think it's one of the easiest classics。 Classics usually take brain energy and willpower to read but not this one。 The plot wasn't even that fun… just some Robert Jordan meeting a guerilla to blow up a bridge。 It was a detailed description of what happens in about the duration of 4 days， and as concise as that is， I got to really experience a part of war that I couldn't have before。 Made me think about death a lot！ 。。。more
Michael C。
，
4。5。 Agree， emotional and brutally strong。 Superb war story relating the downtrodden souls caught in a civil war with a true idealistic American ally immersed in the struggle。Another doomed love story！
Darren Hawley
，
FantasticThe dialogue is written in unique prose that is foreign and beautiful。 Where such stories come from such as these are a great mystery to me。 Hemingway is a master of his craft。
Aimee King
，
Strike two， Hemingway。 You have one more。 Maybe。 “Boring” seems like such a reductive， cop-out term， so I will say dull。 So dull。 If you read the Wikipedia summary， there are two short paragraphs and two long paragraphs。 The best part of the last two paragraphs （where most of the action in this book is） are in the last couple hours of this 16-hour book。 What was the rest of the book about， you say？ Good question。 Mostly， it’s a book with people sitting around talking。 Which can still be compelli Strike two， Hemingway。 You have one more。 Maybe。 “Boring” seems like such a reductive， cop-out term， so I will say dull。 So dull。 If you read the Wikipedia summary， there are two short paragraphs and two long paragraphs。 The best part of the last two paragraphs （where most of the action in this book is） are in the last couple hours of this 16-hour book。 What was the rest of the book about， you say？ Good question。 Mostly， it’s a book with people sitting around talking。 Which can still be compelling。 Hemingway did not make it so。 There is a love story。 I thought it would carry me through if that darn blank slate of a main character didn’t。 Not so。 He calls her “Rabbit，” which should tell you everything you need to know about their relationship。 Here’s a writing gem （it went on in this vein for longer than it should have）:Oh， now， now， now， the only now， and above all now， and there is no other now but thou now and now is thy prophet。It seems poetic， written on a page。 But someone reads it out loud， it is utterly hilarious。 Also， it was amusing that Hemingway censured himself。 “I obscenity in your milk！” was said often。 。。。more
vivi noelani
，
i didn’t technically finish this， so i’d feel annoying if i rated it （i should probably start from beginning and actually finish the thing， but im not sure my heart can take that right now） and i also have absolutely no idea how to begin to explain how i feel about this book or hemingway himself。 i hadn’t read any hemingway since i was a lot younger （3 years is a lot of time no matter what anybody says）， up until last month when i read “Hills Like White Elephants” for both my literature classes。 i didn’t technically finish this， so i’d feel annoying if i rated it （i should probably start from beginning and actually finish the thing， but im not sure my heart can take that right now） and i also have absolutely no idea how to begin to explain how i feel about this book or hemingway himself。 i hadn’t read any hemingway since i was a lot younger （3 years is a lot of time no matter what anybody says）， up until last month when i read “Hills Like White Elephants” for both my literature classes。 the vibe i get from his writing is different now。 i keep remembering my teacher for english 2 saying something along the lines of， “people say hemingway hated women。 i’m not sure i agree。 it’s possible。 however， i think it’s more likely he felt intimidated by them。” that confused the heck out of little sophomore me， to say the least。 i should really start using capital letters again。 。。。more
Miguel Campos
，
Este livro relata os quatro dias em que o especialista em explosivos， Robert Jordan， se junta à guerrilha que nas montanhas defende o legitimo governo da República， contra o golpe fascista， em Espanha。Robert Jordan estabelece uma relação próxima com os corajosos homens e mulheres que， praticamente sem condições， entregavam a vida em nome das suas convicções。É uma bela história onde se misturam valores como a amizade， a honra， a honestidade， a humildade e o amor。 Valores por que vale a pena lutar Este livro relata os quatro dias em que o especialista em explosivos， Robert Jordan， se junta à guerrilha que nas montanhas defende o legitimo governo da República， contra o golpe fascista， em Espanha。Robert Jordan estabelece uma relação próxima com os corajosos homens e mulheres que， praticamente sem condições， entregavam a vida em nome das suas convicções。É uma bela história onde se misturam valores como a amizade， a honra， a honestidade， a humildade e o amor。 Valores por que vale a pena lutar。 。。。more
MS
，
"But I won't keep a count of people I have killed as though it were a trophy record or a disgusting business like notches in a gun， he told himself。 I have a right to not keep count and I have a right to forget them。 No， himself said。 You have no right to forget anything。 You have no right to shut your eyes to any of it nor any right to forget any of it nor to soften it nor to change it。" "There is no such thing as the shortness of time， though。 You should have sense enough to know that too。 I h "But I won't keep a count of people I have killed as though it were a trophy record or a disgusting business like notches in a gun， he told himself。 I have a right to not keep count and I have a right to forget them。 No， himself said。 You have no right to forget anything。 You have no right to shut your eyes to any of it nor any right to forget any of it nor to soften it nor to change it。" "There is no such thing as the shortness of time， though。 You should have sense enough to know that too。 I have been all my life in these hills since I have been here。 Anselmo is my oldest friend。 I know him better than I know Charles， than I know Chub， than I know Guy， than I know Mike， and I know them well。 Agustín， with his vile mouth， is my brother， and I never had a brother。 Maria is my true love and my wife。 I never had a true love。 I never had a wife。 She is also my sister， and I never had a sister， and my daughter， and I never will have a daughter。 I hate to leave a thing that is so good。"This is probably the best novel by Ernest Hemingway， aside from his novella， "The Old Man and The Sea" which is his best work。 Also true for the main character。 Robert Jordan's personality is well polished and rather sympathetic。 Again like "The Old Man and The Sea"， this book is narrated in third person， and the characters talk to themselves a great deal throughout the book， and it serves very well to introduce their insights and personality traits。 The story is engaging and there is some battle， which is good since Hemingway thrives on action。 Despite being a complete bore when it comes to writing romance。 Nevertheless he has done much better here than his two previous books I read。Side characters are likeable， except Pilar， who is a big freaking weirdo， that woman was just too complicated for a human being， and I was so confused whenever she talked or did something， also afraid that she would do something drastic at some point。 But the rest I could live with。 The best thing is that as the story progresses， Hemingway gets better at telling it， slowly building up intensity and excitement towards the end。 And here you can really dig deep through his personality and join him in a quest to discover his thoughts and ideals， and I assure you he has some grand ones。 。。。more
Lucien
，
Loved this book ！ Great themes， uselessness of war， duty， love etc。。。my 1st Hemingway。。。and not my last ！
Ankur Pandit
，
Good read overall but doesn't really get interesting until about halfway through the book。 More accurate rating would be a 3。5/5， but rating it a 4 on this system。 Good read overall but doesn't really get interesting until about halfway through the book。 More accurate rating would be a 3。5/5， but rating it a 4 on this system。 。。。more
Laura
，
"For what are we born if not to aid one another？"Beautifully written story of loyalty， duty， and love。 I savored the writing。 The battle plans and reminiscences held me back from giving it the full five stars。 Great book！ "For what are we born if not to aid one another？"Beautifully written story of loyalty， duty， and love。 I savored the writing。 The battle plans and reminiscences held me back from giving it the full five stars。 Great book！ 。。。more
Joel Alex
，
Hemingway writes a yarn about the patriotic dedication towards freedom against the Spanish Fascists。 Jordan， an American fighting in the Spanish Civil War， falls in love， questions his role in war， the meaning of life， and sniffs out cowardice and treason。 Hemingway introduces the character simply by his actions and words through his conversation， but as danger and threat of life approach we become witness to his inner monologue。 This book （like all of Hemingway） is going to stick with me， his i Hemingway writes a yarn about the patriotic dedication towards freedom against the Spanish Fascists。 Jordan， an American fighting in the Spanish Civil War， falls in love， questions his role in war， the meaning of life， and sniffs out cowardice and treason。 Hemingway introduces the character simply by his actions and words through his conversation， but as danger and threat of life approach we become witness to his inner monologue。 This book （like all of Hemingway） is going to stick with me， his idealized version of what a person should be， his construct of masculinity （while I certainly don't agree with） has shaped our culture。 What to fight for？ What to die for？ Powerful questions， if his objective was to make the reader look at war and wonder if it is worth it， to see the fog of morality and still decide; despite both sides being mired in hate， wrong and injustice， then he succeeded。 A couple of things about this book that I did not enjoy; thou， thine， thy， thee， a nearly whole chapter of a young Spanish woman swooning over the American （"I will take marriage classes to be a better wife for thee if thou desire" - may have flown in the 1940s but it has certainly lost it any romantic luster， if it had any to begin with）。 Lots of war， lots of random conversations， lots of Jordan thinking people were smart or really stupid （but still very brave）， bull fighting （of course）， GUN talk！， gendered stereotypes， racial and ethnic stereotypes， and loads of political partisan politics。 Overall， it is a classic。 Hemingway can write， his literary devices enhance his novels， his style helped formed thousands of writers and modern media， and this book makes you think and live more deeply。 All of those are what good literature should do。 。。。more
Sondos
，
فکر میکنم یکی از دلایل اصلی ناشناخته یا کم شناخته ماندن همینگوی و آثارش در ایران، ترجمههای افتضاح باشد。 این کتاب را به یاد ایام نوجوانی و «کتاب شب» دوباره خواندم。 ترجمه واقعاً دیوانه کننده است。درباره کتاب:با خواندن این کتاب میتوانید بفهمید که عملیات غیرنظامی، چریکی و پارتیزانی چرا هیچ وقت درست و حسابی جواب نمیدهد。 هیچ کس به دیگری اعتماد ندارد و تقریباً همه منتظر فرارسیدن پیروزی برای پاکسازی هستند。 یعنی در نهایت خودشان تبدیل به موجودیتی میشوند که در حال مبارزه با آن هستند。پ。ن: ستاره نمیدم چ فکر میکنم یکی از دلایل اصلی ناشناخته یا کم شناخته ماندن همینگوی و آثارش در ایران، ترجمههای افتضاح باشد。 این کتاب را به یاد ایام نوجوانی و «کتاب شب» دوباره خواندم。 ترجمه واقعاً دیوانه کننده است。درباره کتاب:با خواندن این کتاب میتوانید بفهمید که عملیات غیرنظامی، چریکی و پارتیزانی چرا هیچ وقت درست و حسابی جواب نمیدهد。 هیچ کس به دیگری اعتماد ندارد و تقریباً همه منتظر فرارسیدن پیروزی برای پاکسازی هستند。 یعنی در نهایت خودشان تبدیل به موجودیتی میشوند که در حال مبارزه با آن هستند。پ。ن: ستاره نمیدم چون این ترجمه اصلاً ارزش یک ستاره هم نداره。 。。。more
Nick H
，
Striking use of language as always。 Hemingway has always had a strong way of portraying various other tongues in English dialects， and his “thy” and “thou” method here is really inspired。 Also loved the way he replaced all the swear words without them feeling any less dirty。 The story itself is the most traditionally structured of his that I’ve read so far。 I think it gets a little tiresome after a while， but there are a lot of memorable moments。 Scott’s narration is very good。 [LIBRARY AUDIOBOO Striking use of language as always。 Hemingway has always had a strong way of portraying various other tongues in English dialects， and his “thy” and “thou” method here is really inspired。 Also loved the way he replaced all the swear words without them feeling any less dirty。 The story itself is the most traditionally structured of his that I’ve read so far。 I think it gets a little tiresome after a while， but there are a lot of memorable moments。 Scott’s narration is very good。 [LIBRARY AUDIOBOOK] 。。。more
Felipe Leite
，
Hemingway direto e reto。 Uma ode aos homens e mulheres q lutaram contra o fascismo na guerra civil espanhola
Kurt Fox
，
Gotta blow up the bridge。 Oh Maria I love thee。 Obscenity in your milk。 The Gypsy。 Hate the fascists。 Pablo， gotta blow up the bridge， Ingles。。。 for 400+ pages。 Leaps and bounds ahead of Sun Also Rises and Farewell to Arms， but still rather boring。。。 which I think captures the essence of war; always wanting to make an impact， but most of the time waiting and sitting around and trying not to let it fall apart at the seams with your crew。 At least his drinking is moderate， and limited to absinthe， Gotta blow up the bridge。 Oh Maria I love thee。 Obscenity in your milk。 The Gypsy。 Hate the fascists。 Pablo， gotta blow up the bridge， Ingles。。。 for 400+ pages。 Leaps and bounds ahead of Sun Also Rises and Farewell to Arms， but still rather boring。。。 which I think captures the essence of war; always wanting to make an impact， but most of the time waiting and sitting around and trying not to let it fall apart at the seams with your crew。 At least his drinking is moderate， and limited to absinthe， wine， whiskey and water。 。。。more
Mehmet
，
Worth reading， mainly because his style is so unusual and I don't know what to make of it。 Worth reading， mainly because his style is so unusual and I don't know what to make of it。 。。。more
Dorottya Tornai
，
Overall I really enjoyed Hemingway's writing style as the 'iceberg technique' truly keeps the reader engaged and invested in the story。 However， I had the impression that some parts were way too descriptive and too much space were dedicated to scenes where nothing with major significance happened。 I appreciated how deeply the characters were elaborated on。 It was interesting and at the same time realistically shocking to observe the detrimental effects of the war on people， how the desire to liv Overall I really enjoyed Hemingway's writing style as the 'iceberg technique' truly keeps the reader engaged and invested in the story。 However， I had the impression that some parts were way too descriptive and too much space were dedicated to scenes where nothing with major significance happened。 I appreciated how deeply the characters were elaborated on。 It was interesting and at the same time realistically shocking to observe the detrimental effects of the war on people， how the desire to live ceases to exist or alters completely。 The brutal reality of the war is equally perfectly depicted - how people are transformed by the violence and the promise of a different political system。 How every drop of empathy， love and compassion is eradicated in the face of a war， still， war does not bypass without leaving its imprint on the human soul。 Even though the book is simultaneously praised for its love story， personally it was not as convincing。 As the whole plot embraces the actions of three days， it is hard to believe that such deep connection could be evolved in that timeframe。 The last 20 pages of the book truly makes the reader cry， as the emotional content of it is really touching。 。。。more
Michael
，
Reading List: Spanish Civil War by Foreigners 1。 Homage to Catalonia by George Orwell2。 Pagan Spain by Richard Wright （post war）3。 For Whom The Bell Tolls by Ernest Hemingway 4。 Days of Hope by Andre Malraux （skip this one）
Micaela ⚡
，
Tiene momentos que me encantaron， especialmente en la segunda parte， pero me costó entrar en la historia。 Igual vale la pena leerlo， no me "mató" como El Viejo y el Mar， pero en líneas generales me gustó。 Tiene momentos que me encantaron， especialmente en la segunda parte， pero me costó entrar en la historia。 Igual vale la pena leerlo， no me "mató" como El Viejo y el Mar， pero en líneas generales me gustó。 。。。more
Mike Cuthbert
，
This classic has been reviewed， discussed and made into doctoral theses enough so that I feel intimidated adding my two cents to the pile， but I read this as an exercise in finding gems from past literature and after watching the Ken Burns series on Hemingway。 I found the experience surprising （the book is over 500 pages long） and somewhat frustrating in its stylistic quirks。 We are to buy the fact that the manuscript was in Spanish， and there is a lot of Spanish used in the text， but it varies。 This classic has been reviewed， discussed and made into doctoral theses enough so that I feel intimidated adding my two cents to the pile， but I read this as an exercise in finding gems from past literature and after watching the Ken Burns series on Hemingway。 I found the experience surprising （the book is over 500 pages long） and somewhat frustrating in its stylistic quirks。 We are to buy the fact that the manuscript was in Spanish， and there is a lot of Spanish used in the text， but it varies。 Sometimes Hemingway translates the Spanish， sometimes not。 He also， for some reason that must be buried in American literature history， adopts a “thee and thou” style for some conversations。 Too， Hemingway refers to his protagonist always as “Robert Jordan。” Sometimes his Spanish nickname， Inglés is used （he is American， not English） and frequently female characters are called “the Maria” and “the Pilar” rather than by their first names only。 The novel， for those of you unfamiliar with it， is set over a few days in the Spanish mountains as Jordan prepares to blow up a bridge before a major assault by rebel （Communist） troops。 As we get closer to Detonation Day， Jordan realizes that the opposition troops， the fascists， have changed position so that they are perfectly aligned to massacre any troops who invade。 He tries to get a message to a General Golz to tell him to stop the attack。 Jordan is further handicapped when an alleged compatriot makes off with the equipment necessary to set off the dynamite under the bridge。 Jordan improvises his way out of that mess but one gets the impression that Jordan is not destined to live long。 The entire mood of the novel， in fact， is one of impending doom and disaster and the love affair between Jordan and the young Maria is also doomed。 There is much contemplation of life and death， much dreaming about a future for the lovers and a silent acceptance of the fact that it is just that: dreaming。 The politics of the war are not central to the plot though the fascist vs。 communist angle is discussed as politics comes into play。 The first half of the novel moves rather slowly but the pace quickly picks up past the halfway point as the attack looms ever closer。 Does the book deserve the “classic” description？ I would agree that it does， if for no other reason than Hemingway’s ability to draw characters vividly and portray action clearly and establish a dominant mood for the novel that， while sad， is truthful and consistent with the times and history。 It is not a light read， however， so be warned to be patient。 And no， I am not going to attempt to make a thesis out of this！ 。。。more
Candy
，
DNF， not in a place to read war right now。 Really wanted to tackle this， maybe later this year。
Monica
，
I absolutely LOVE this book， I love the plot and everything about this！！ I highly recommend it。 I want you to know， there is a competition happening this April till the end of May on the NovelStar app。 I hope you can consider joining。 You can also publish your stories there。 just email our editors hardy@novelstar。top， joye@novelstar。top， or lena@novelstar。top。
Майя Ставитская
，
Hemingway is not my writer。 Except for the Fiesta。 And "The Holiday that is always with you"， in the part where the company wanders from bar to bar， drinking， polishing， smoothing one alcohol with another and a third。 And observing the change in the quality of perception that accompanies the process。 I read it at the age of sixteen， and I promised myself that I would definitely repeat the feat。 It didn't work out， I was weak to a mixture of malt alcohols with wine。 Or maybe it's the lack of good Hemingway is not my writer。 Except for the Fiesta。 And "The Holiday that is always with you"， in the part where the company wanders from bar to bar， drinking， polishing， smoothing one alcohol with another and a third。 And observing the change in the quality of perception that accompanies the process。 I read it at the age of sixteen， and I promised myself that I would definitely repeat the feat。 It didn't work out， I was weak to a mixture of malt alcohols with wine。 Or maybe it's the lack of good company？But the titles of his books from childhood touched a sensitive chord in the soul: "For whom the bell tolls"， "And the sun rises"， "Across the river， in the shade of the trees" （the title is the dying words of General Jackson， uttered on the day of my birth， a century and a little earlier 。 "Let's cross the river and rest in the shade of the trees"）。 Не мой писатель， Хемингуэй。 Вот разве "Фиеста"。 И "Праздник， который всегда с тобой"， в той части， где компания кочует из бара в бар， выпивая， полируя， заглаживая один алкоголь другим и третьим。 И наблюдая за изменением качества восприятия， сопутствующим процессу。 Прочла лет в шестнадцать， дала себе слово непременно повторить подвиг。 Ничего не вышло， слаба оказалась к смеси солодовых спиртов с винными。 А может， дело в отсутствии хорошей компании？ Но названия его книг с детства задевали в душе какую-то чувствительную струну: "По ком звонит колокол"， "И всходит солнце"， "За рекой， в тени деревьев" （заглавие - предсмертные слова генерала Джексона， произнесенные в день моего рождения， на век с небольшим раньше 。 "Переправимся через реку и отдохнем в тени деревьев"）。 "Колокол" читала в девицах， две трети жизни назад и сюжет помню смутно。 Ругать Хемингуэя за мачизм сегодня стало общим местом。 Однако напомню， что судим мы с позиций дня сегодняшнего， когда рулит феминизм。 В то время， как в конце восьмидесятых прошлого века маскулинность мужской военной прозы не казалась чрезмерной。 Даже напротив， воспринималась как естественная。 Мужественный американец， пришедший воевать за идею。 Прекрасная хрупкая сестра милосердия。 Рвущая душу， трагичная история любви。 Мощный антивоенный пафос в сочетании с лаконичной， ни на что прежде читаное не похожей повествовательной манерой: простые короткие слова， много глаголов и минимум прилагательных - это было круто。 Еще эпиграф из Джона Донна， тогда затвердила эти стихи наизусть с пары прочтений и поняла， что эпиграф страшная сила。 。。。more
Julia
，
One of the worst books I’ve ever read。 I can’t believe I made it to the end。
Tomas Nilsson
，
A masterpiece！
Amaure
，
I’ve lost count of how many times I’ve read your book。 That’s the great thing about an amazing novel， you can read it over and over and get something new out of it。 。。。 If you have some great stories like this one， you can publish it on Novel Star， just submit your story to hardy@novelstar。top or joye@novelstar。top
Mark Stirrat
，
This and A Farwell to Arms are my two favorite novels。 EH's style and characters grab a hold of my attention from the first page and don't let go until the end。 They stay with me for a long time。 Tried so many different authors over the years but always come back to these。 This and A Farwell to Arms are my two favorite novels。 EH's style and characters grab a hold of my attention from the first page and don't let go until the end。 They stay with me for a long time。 Tried so many different authors over the years but always come back to these。 。。。more
Miguel Rodríguez Gómez
，
Por quién doblan las campanas es un libro que toca cerca， en gran parte por tratar sobre la Guerra Civil Española a través de un grupo de guerrilleros republicanos。 Es una novela algo imperfecta， porque el ritmo al principio es pesado， el personaje principal es muy plano， pero contiene momentos brillantes。Contada desde el punto de vista de un soldado estadounidense， el principal contenido reside en las conversaciones que tiene éste con un grupo de guerrilleros de la sierra de Guadarrama， en sus Por quién doblan las campanas es un libro que toca cerca， en gran parte por tratar sobre la Guerra Civil Española a través de un grupo de guerrilleros republicanos。 Es una novela algo imperfecta， porque el ritmo al principio es pesado， el personaje principal es muy plano， pero contiene momentos brillantes。Contada desde el punto de vista de un soldado estadounidense， el principal contenido reside en las conversaciones que tiene éste con un grupo de guerrilleros de la sierra de Guadarrama， en sus recuerdos sobre la guerra civil， la vida que tenían antes y cómo ven （si es que hay） el futuro。 Tienen que llevar a cabo en un par de días una ofensiva con baja probabilidad de supervivencia。 Hay imágenes impactantes， como el relato de una mujer sobre cómo en su pueblo mataron colectivamente a los fascistas que había， el impacto que tuvo sobre ellos y la reacción de la gente。 Muestra la guerra de forma cruda， humanizando a las personas que mueren en ella （fascistas y republicanos）， y aparecen tanto personajes idealistas como cínicos y pesimistas。 El personaje principal tiene el carisma de una piedra， aunque a medida que avanza la historia， al sentirse cercano de los guerrilleros （y especialmente de una chica con la que tiene un romance）， empiezan a brotar de él emociones， y hacia al final de la obra tiene monólogos internos muy humanos e interesantes。 Un problema es que la personalidad de dicha chica consiste únicamente en estar enamorada del protagonista y querer complacerle。 También el principio es lento， pesado， y hay partes de diálogos o descripciones que， al menos a mí， me han saturado。 Aún así， el contenido de la obra compensa estos desperfectos， especialmente las conversaciones de los guerrilleros， sus crisis de fé， sus reflexiones sobre la guerra， sus deseos。。。 Dicho todo esto， hay relatos e imágenes que recordaré durante mucho tiempo。 。。。more
Anneka
，
"He had only one thing to do and that was what he should think about and he must think it out clearly and take everything as it came along， and not worry。 To worry was a bad as to be afraid。 It simply made things more difficult。"Glad I finally completed it， but not the most interesting！The rambling of innermost thoughts was a bit overwhelming at times， although I think it was very appropriate to include much of it as it was telling as to how thoughts continue and seem waffle-y at times even for "He had only one thing to do and that was what he should think about and he must think it out clearly and take everything as it came along， and not worry。 To worry was a bad as to be afraid。 It simply made things more difficult。"Glad I finally completed it， but not the most interesting！The rambling of innermost thoughts was a bit overwhelming at times， although I think it was very appropriate to include much of it as it was telling as to how thoughts continue and seem waffle-y at times even for trained soldiers。 。。。more
fคrຊคຖ。tຖ
，
شبیه وداع با اسلحه بود؛ جنگ و عشق و پایانی تلخ。 البته اونو بیشتر دوست داشتم
Reference
google book https://www.google.com/search?tbm=bks&q=For Whom the Bell Tolls
hathitrust digital library https://babel.hathitrust.org/cgi/ls?q1=For Whom the Bell Tolls&field1=ocr&a=srchls&ft=ft&lmt=ft